Toddy BPA-Free Cold Brew Coffee Maker, 37-Ounce
Last updated: March 4, 2022
We looked at the top Cold Brew Coffee Makers and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Cold Brew Coffee Maker you should buy.
Product Details
In our analysis of 163 expert reviews, the Toddy BPA-Free Cold Brew Coffee Maker, 37-Ounce placed 10th when we looked at the top 13 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.From The Manufacturer
Designed to brew coffee with 67-percent less acid than coffee made with hot brew methods, the Toddy Cold Brew System also makes tea, hot or cold. The patented cold brew system uses regular coffee beans to create a super smooth cup of steaming hot coffee as is often found in major coffee houses, but with no electricity required. The set includes a brewing container with handle, glass decanter with lid, two reusable filters, one rubber stopper, a set of instructions, and a recipe guide. Get more out of your coffee beans, since the coffee concentrate stays fresh for up to three weeks.
Our Expert Consultant
Julie Chernoff
Culinary Expert
Culinary Expert
Julie Chernoff is a long-time member of Les Dames d’Escoffier (past president of the Chicago Chapter, and current co-chair of the LDEI Legacy Awards Committee), the Association of Food Journalists (AFJ) and the International Association of Culinary Professionals.
Chernoff is the dining editor of Better, a lifestyle website and print magazine. Her journalism started in the test kitchens of Weight Watchers Magazine. She holds a BA in English from Yale University and is a graduate of the California Culinary Academy. She has spent the last few decades styling, photographing, teaching, developing recipes, editing, thinking and writing about food.
Expert Reviews
What reviewers liked
The Toddy Cold Brew System is an inexpensive way to make a large volume of cold brew coffee without much hassle. The cold brew the Toddy creates is concentrated, strong, yet smooth, sweet and delicious. The Toddy system has only a few parts and is a snap to assemble.
While it's made almost completely from plastic, the reusable filter makes up for the environmental impact a little, and the glass decanter is one of the most durable out there, and pretty enough to use as a serving vessel. Todd Simpson is undoubtedly the father of modern cold brew, and it should come as no surprise that it took a coffee-loving chemical engineer to devise the perfect brewer to eliminate coffee acid and produce a heavy, smooth, silky iced coffee with almost no hassle.
Fortunately, it makes rich, full-bodied cold-brewed coffee that tastes as robust as any other method I’ve tried so far, sometimes better.
- Wired
The Toddy Cold Brew System has a long track record of providing a great balance of simplicity and flavor.
The Toddy Cold Brew system is perhaps the best known, and is used by Seattle’s Best and many other coffee shop chains for making their iced coffee drinks. One immediate upside to the cold brewing method is low acidity. In fact, Toddy claims to reduce the usual acidity of hot-brewed coffee by as much as 67%. That’s good news for coffee lovers with delicate stomachs.
Toddy is one of the most known cold press brewing systems, is the oldest cold brew system, and most trusted one. It is a simple system, built with durable materials, to ensure it a long life. The brewing kit includes: a brewing container, a glass decanter, (56 oz), felt filter pads, paper filter bags, and a rubber stopper for the brewing container.
In other words, all the coffee grounds sit in this paper filter bag. So when the coffee is done brewing, you simply let all the cold brew coffee concentrate drain, then discard this bag. It makes clean up a breeze.
You’ll get a highly concentrate coffee you can enjoy cold without the acidity you’d find with a hot brewing process.
The Toddy is the most popular cold brew solution at the moment. It’s easy to use, makes huge quantities, and you can use either the standard felt filter, or add an additional paper filter, which creates an even smoother brew.
You can make hot and cold brews with this coffee maker. Your favorite beverage will stay fresh up to two weeks after brewing.
- Heavy
Brews both coffee and tea. Coffee concentrate lasts up to three weeks. Much less acid in your morning cup of java.
Comes with two reusable wool and paper filters. Simple to use and easy to store.
The machine is lightweight and small size for simple placement and storage.
Many customers report that this maker is reliable and produces a good cup of coffee consistently.
Also makes tea, served hot or cold, Brewing container with handle, glass decanter with lid, rubber stopper, and two reusable filters included, Includes recipe guide, Concentrate stays fresh for up to 3 weeks.
The cloth filter is a very unique design of the Toddy that makes it stand out in a list of coffee makers.
Dual filtration and classic methods allow for some customization and tweaking.
This glass cold brew coffee maker — which can be used to brew coffee or tea — comes with reusable filters and a glass decanter and is compact enough to sit on your kitchen counter without taking up loads of space. It comes with directions for making seven cups of super-concentrated brew that can later be mixed with two to three parts water or milk — which means you're getting 14 to 21 cups of actual coffee.
- Bustle
Serves double duty for hot and cold coffee. Reusable felt filters do the job brilliantly without costing you a fortune in ongoing expenses. Set-up included everything you need to start brewing straight out the box with a recipe guide for added inspiration.
The great thing is you can use the Toddy to infuse tea hot or cold.
Extremely user-friendly design and no electricity is required. Easy Cleaning Process.
It uses a patented wool fiber-based filtration system that’s easy to handle and clean.
]By virtue of the general process, you also get greater control over the brew temperature and strength. The versatility is a reason Toddy is incredibly well received and is considered among the best cold brew coffee makers.
It is a good and practical budget cold brew system. The benefits of brewing in a filter are reduced clean-up, plus both the decanter and brewer are dishwasher safe.
It is lightweight and easy to handle. Easy to store.
The other great thing is you can use it to make hot or iced tea. Included with your set you receive the infuse container with a handle, two reusable filters, glass decanter with a lid, one rubber stopper, a recipe guide, and instructions.
The Toddy is a cold brew maker focused on simple function. As such it’s one of the more popular brewers for two simple reasons. It makes great coffee and it’s super easy to clean.
For people who love the smoothness and flavor of the chilly method but want something to keep them warm in the winter, the tried and true Toddy System produces a low-acid cup that is actually designed to be drunk hot. It can also be used to make tea.
Toddy is one of the most popular cold press brewing systems. In fact, it’s among the oldest cold brew systems—if not the oldest. The system is simple, and is built with durable materials. It therefore has a long lifespan. Included in the system are a glass decanter, brewing container, rubber stopper, paper filter bags, and felt filter pads.
Great for brewing both tea and coffee. ]Larger coffee brewing capacity Reusable, cost-saving filters. Free recipe book included.
Can brew a lot or a little coffee. Very easy to use. Small, light, and easy to transport.
Foolproof plastic construction. Effective filtration. Simple procedure. Large volume. Quality storage carafe with snug-fitting lid.
The decanter is made of high-quality clear glass. This enables you to see the content trickle in as you wait impatiently. It also has a lid that lets you close the decanter after brewing to keep away contaminants from entering your delicious brew.
Consistent to produce great-flavored coffee.
What reviewers didn't like
Like many manual cold brew coffee products, brewing with the Toddy system takes some practice to perfect. The Toddy Cold Brew System is also tall and eats up some counter space when brewing. The Toddy can't use paper filters and comes with just one reusable felt filter and rubber stopper.
You have to remove a rubber stopper to drain the coffee after 24 hours, which will always get your hands messy—cleanup is time-consuming.
- Wired
Doesn't have a lid, long-term durability concerns.
Can be tough to find replacement filters. Plastic components seem flimsy.
- Heavy
Concentrate must be manually heated or cooled.
Brewing container is plastic. Rubber stoppers may need to be replaced. Takes a while to drain after brewing.
Clean up process is not seamless.
However, some customers have noted that the process of removing the stopper to drain the brewed coffee into the decanter is complicated and messy. Ultimately this brewer is more challenging to use than other models on the market today. Additionally, the plastic construction of the brewing device is a turn-off for many consumers.
Some users have complained that the product is a little complicated in its use, but with time you will get used to it.
Poorly-designed brewing chamber makes it awkward to pour coffee concentrate into the carafe. The 56 oz capacity may be too much for someone looking to make one or two servings at a time.
Slightly flimsier than some of the competition so handle with care.
Difficult to find the replacement filters
Made of plastic and hence, it can get cracked. The rubber Stopper leaks.
Could use a better look.
Unfortunately, the Toddy Cold Brewer materials are as frail as they look. For making a cold brew every now and then we felt comfortable using, but for those that like to have a cold brew on tap, you might need to replace it fairly quickly!
Cleaning is not as easy as it looks. The plastic rim is shallow.
Make sure to place the rubber stopper correctly in the brewer. You need to purchase new filters.
Plastic handle feels a little flimsy. Instructions are a little fiddly.
The smaller, at home brewer doesn't come with paper filters as the commercial size brewer does. Not aesthetically pleasing.
Batch volume is a bit generous for one person. No lid for brewer. Lackluster aesthetics. Stopper removal can be messy.
Sometimes the container is too heavy. Takes a lot of time to prepare.
Much smaller compared to other home coffee makers. Plastic-made immersion receptacle.
View our Cold Brew Coffee Maker buying guide for in-depth advice and recommendations.